From 2012 to 2013, approximately 16 New York residents reported vague, nonspecific adverse health effects which included fatigue, loss of scalp hair, and muscle aches. One patient was hospitalized for liver damage. An epidemiological investigation identified a common factor among these patients; the consumption of B-50 vitamin and multimineral supplements from the same supplier. To investigate whether these nutritional supplements might have been responsible for the adverse health effects observed, comprehensive chemical analyses of marketed lots of the supplements were performed. To determine presence of organic components and contaminants, organic extracts of samples were prepared and analyzed using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), liquid chromatography high-resolution mass spectrometry (LC-HRMS), and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). These analyses revealed the presence of significant levels of methasterone (17β-hydroxy-2α,17α-dimethyl-5α-androstane-3-one), an androgenic steroid and schedule III-controlled substance; dimethazine, an azine-linked dimer of methasterone; and methylstenbolone (2,17α-dimethyl-17β-hydroxy-5α-androst-1-en-3-one), a related androgenic steroid. Methasterone and extracts of certain supplement capsules were identified as highly androgenic in luciferase assays by using an androgen receptor promoter construct. This androgenicity persisted for several days after cell exposure to the compounds. The presence of these components in implicated lots were associated with adverse health effects and the hospitalization of one patient and the presentation of symptoms of severe virilization in a child. These findings underscore the need for more rigorous oversight of the nutritional supplement industry.